Royal Canin vs Blue Buffalo

Comparison Royal Canin vs Blue Buffalo Dog Food In 2021 

When it comes to your dogs, you always want what's the best for them, right? You cannot just feed them with whatever is available on the table or pantry. You have to know what their nutritional needs are.

So, how do you choose dog food? Do high-quality ingredients matter to you? Are you the kind of pet owner who consults with the vet first? Or do you stick to whatever is popular and has a cute packaging?

In this article, we will help you get to know the two of the most popular dog food brands in the market–Royal Canin and Blue Buffalo. To get you an idea, these brands are trusted and safe for your dogs. Plus, they have the best-selling dog food products in the market for several years already.

Let us see which brand is better in terms of quality ingredients, nutritional value, product safety, and other important factors to consider.

Most Popular Royal Canin Dog Foods In 2021

History on Royal Canin

Royal Canin is the type of brand that goes beyond and learn how different dogs process and digest their food. By doing combined scientific and nutritional research, it is able to make the product the perfect diet for all types of breeds. This brand is considered to be a leader when it comes to innovation and sales of products. So far, they have carefully examined and analyzed the different needs of pets of all ages, lifestyles, and breeds. In other words, they put importance on tailored nutrition.

Royal Canin has studied the unique health needs of pets in the smallest of details. According to the brand's researchers, the smallest nutritional differences can make a huge difference to your pet's life and health.

It created every recipe to have an individual formula to deliver the exact level of natural antioxidants, prebiotics, fiber, vitamins, and minerals that are essential in the diet. Everything is also tested and has to meet certain quality standards before it is processed into food.

Royal Canin Golden Retriever Adult Breed Specific Dry Dog Food

royal caninCheck Latest Price
This product is formulated for Golden Retrievers 15 months and older. The unique kibble shape and texture are specifically for your Golden's straight muzzle and scissor bite, encouraging them to chew properly. Its exclusive amount of nutrients and vitamins will help reinforce the skin barrier to protect skin and helo maintain the golden fur and fluffy coat. 

The precise amount of fat and calories in the product will also help your Golden Retriever maintain their weight at targeted nutrition.
Pros:
  • helps in relieving skin problems
  • help in slowly chewing the food for proper digestion
  • smells good
Cons:
  • contains potential allergens

Royal Canin Labrador Retriever Adult Breed Specific Dry Dog Food

royal canin labCheck Latest Price
This dog food for Labrador Retrievers is designed to meet the nutritional needs of purebred Labrador Retrievers 15 months and older. Also, it reinforces the skin barrier with essential nutrients to support healthy skin and dense undercoats. The kibbles are designed with a specific shape, size, and texture for each dog's facial and jaw structures and biting patterns that affect the way they pick up kibble. 

Plus, it supports bone & joint health with EPA, DHA, and glucosamine to support large, strong bodies
Pros:
  • vet-recommended
  • recommended for picky-eaters
  • helps the coat glows
Cons:
  • has a lesser amount of vitamins and minerals

Royal Canin Yorkshire Terrier Adult Breed Specific Dry Dog Food

royal canin yorkie best foodCheck Latest Price
Royal Canin Yorkshire Terrier Adult dry dog food is perfectly formulated to meet the nutritional needs of purebred Yorkshire Terriers 10 months and older. It has high palatability with exceptional aromas and flavors to satisfy picky appetites and exclusively designed for a Yorkshire Terrier’s small muzzle and bite, making it easy for them to pick up and chew. 

The optimal levels of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids and biotin content help give your Yorkshire Terrier’s long coat a beautiful shine.
Pros:
  • can be chewed easily
  • can help dogs feel full for longer
  • eases digestive problems
Cons:
  • more expensive

Most Popular Blue Buffalo Dog Foods In 2021

History On Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo brand started when their family dog was experiencing health problems. The brand owners decided it would be best if they would give handle it in a natural way, giving their dog natural and high-quality food.

Sadly, the market at that time has no "natural dog food" to offer. The only thing that was left for them was to make their own food. With that, it helped the dog to prolong his life and live for another 10 years. So, the owners continued to do what was supposed to be for emergency purposes only. In fact, they claim that the key to treating your dog properly is to give them the kind of food that you would also be taking as a human.

Blue Buffalo labels their products according to dog's specialties such as Life Protection Formula, Freedom, Wilderness, Basics and Natural Veterinary Diet.

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Natural Adult Dry Dog Food

buffalo blueCheck Latest Price
Blue Buffalo dog foods have always been offering real meat as the first ingredient. High-quality protein from real chicken helps your dog build and maintain healthy muscles. Plus, they contain wholesome whole grains garden veggies and fruit. 

Moreover, BLUE Life Protection Formula adult dog food contains essential proteins and carbohydrates to help meet the energy needs of adult dogs and features omega 3 & 6 fatty acids to promote a shiny coat and healthy skin.
Pros:
  • gives healthy skin and coat
  • more protein content for stronger muscles
  • contains real meat
Cons:
  • moderately expensive

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Natural Adult Small Breed Dry Dog Food

 Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Natural Adult Small Breed Dry Dog FoodCheck Latest Price
This product is specially formulated for the wellness of adult small breed dogs BLUE Life Protection Formula Small Breed dry dog food. It contains increased levels of protein and carbohydrates to meet the energy needs of smaller dogs with a kibble size ideal for smaller jaws. 

The formula has a precise blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals carefully selected by holistic veterinarians and animal nutritionists, to support immune system health, life stage requirements, and a healthy oxidative balance.
Pros:
  • can relieve diarrhea
  • no preservatives and animal by-products
  • promotes glowing coat
Cons:
  • the kibbles have the same size as adult kibbles

Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein, Natural Adult Dry Dog Food

Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein, Natural Adult Dry Dog FoodCheck Latest Price
The BLUE Wilderness grain-free adult dog food is made with healthy carbohydrates including sweet potatoes and peas to help fuel your adult dog's active lifestyle. Plus it contains omega 3 & 6 fatty acids to support skin and coat health. 

This is also another recipe that is made to satisfy your dog's natural love for meat this high protein dog food features real chicken to help build and maintain lean muscle mass. Importantly, it never contains chicken (or poultry) by-product meals corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or preservatives.
Pros:
  • recommend to those that deal with pitbull allergies
  • does not contain many dog food fillers
  • grain-free
Cons:
  • expensive
  • much of the protein comes from plants

Royal Canin vs Blue Buffalo Ingredients

Royal Canin and Blue Buffalo have different ways of promoting every dog's health and balanced nutrition. Blue Buffalo focuses more on the natural approach while Royal Canin goes for science-based in formulating their dry and wet dog food. It is already up to the buyers what they will choose.

Moreover, Royal Canin focuses more on the finished products that have a lot to do with meats and wheat in enough quantities. Every product from this brand goes through a series of quality control tests to make sure it is no less than perfect. But it also uses some ingredients which many consider controversial such as by-products and wheat. 

While Blue Buffalo has more fruits and vegetables, as well as natural vitamins and minerals with no fillers and grains. They also offer gluten-free products with no artificial flavorings, coloring, or preservatives. But just like Royal Canin, there are also some controversial ingredients that this brand uses.

Protein 

Do you know that without protein, dogs can develop different health problems? Just like humans, they also need a good amount and source of protein for their development and sustenance. With Blue Buffalo, it goes by more than 2.20% of protein compared to Royal Canin. though it has a small difference, it still makes sense especially if your dog has health problems such as kidney disease or obesity. But if your dog's special diet must have a low-protein content, then you must choose the Royal Canin. Never forget to read the nutritional label at the back of each bag.

Fat

Fats provide your dogs a good amount of energy and are essential for their development and body function, that is why fats should be present in their everyday meals. Plus, it is able to give your pets prostaglandins that reduce inflammation and other serious complications in the body. 

Blue Buffalo and Royal Canin have the same amount of fats in their food. However, Blue Buffalo has more fat contents in their wet dog foods. To choose the best product, it is always best to consult with a veterinarian to figure out what's best for your dogs.  

Fiber

Fiber is very important in helping with digestion and other digestive problems like diarrhea and constipation. It can also help in improving weight management and colon health, hence making it essential in the diet. 

Blue Buffalo offers about 5% of fiber while Royal Canin has only 3.2%. However, Royal Canin gives 2.66% more of the component in their wet dog food. 

Omega-6

Omega-6 fatty acids are essential for their diet. It can help cell membrane structure and cell function. These are also needed in reproduction, healthy growth, glowing coat and skin, as well as strength in their immune system. Omega-6 is also a type of fat and can contribute to your dog's calorie intake so, it is better to watch out how much they should take this component. 

Also, most of these fatty acids are made up of sunflower, canola, soybean, corn, and safflower oil. Royal Canin consists of 0.48% fatty acids while Blue Buffalo has 2.4% of these.

Controversial ingredients

Controversial ingredients in dog foods are zero to less nutritional value and may be harmful to the dogs. Though these ingredients will not necessarily kill the pets, they can certainly cause severe health problems in the long run. 

Royal Canin and Blue Buffalo both use the following controversial ingredients in their products:

  • pea protein
  • tomato pomace
  • caramel
  • powdered cellulose
  • dried tomato pomace

Here are some of the controversial ingredients that are used by Royal Canin:

  • corn, cornflour, cornmeal, and corn grits
  • beef and pork plasma
  • brewers rice and brewers rice flour
  • propyl gallate
  • animal by-products
  • wheat and wheat  gluten
  • canola meal
  • corn gluten meal
  • rice hulls
  • vegetable oil
  • soybean protein isolate

Blue Buffalo also has its list of controversial ingredients such as:

  • Garlic
  • Canola oil
  • caramel color
  • pea protein concentrate

It only has a few since the brand focuses on being natural and healthy.  

But all of these listed ingredients have different effects on your dogs. That is why it is important to check with the vet first or feed them in small portions occasionally.

Moreover, there are also some ingredients that are linked to having adverse health effects and are classified as really harmful.

Royal Canin has Bha and Menadione Sodium Bisulfite Complex while Blue Buffalo has Menadione Sodium Bisulfate Complex only.

Feeding Guide 

Regardless of what brand of dog food you choose, you have to follow its suggested feeding guide to benefit from it entirely. You do not have to worry since these brands have their own veterinarians and other health experts to consult from. Also, both brands offer a simple, detailed chart on the back of every packaging. 

Royal Canin

Royal Canin classifies dogs by age, stage of life, or special needs. With that, almost every dog food product has a different feeding guide that applies. Most charts on the back have suggested cups per day recommended for a certain weight of the pet but this may vary depending on the breed and diet. The brand believes that every dog is unique and has breed-specific traits that forced them to create precise nutrition for dogs. In other words, different dog breeds have different nutrition. 

Most importantly, pay special attention if your dog is on a special diet that is a mixture of two different types of Royal Canin. Make sure to follow the suggested feeding guide but if you are unsure about how much your pet should intake per day, contact your nearest vet or the brand itself. 

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo offers feeding guidelines that work the same way depending on your pet's weight and the daily recommended serving. However, Blue Buffalo does not classify dogs by breeds, unlike Royal Canin. It means you will not be able to find food for protection hounds, golden retriever puppies, or chihuahuas. This is because Blue Buffalo believes that a dog's way of eating has very little to do with the breed but has more to do with its activity level and way of life. Still, recommended doses vary especially for canned or wet dog foods. Make sure to check how to dose if you decide to treat your dog with a new type of food.

Product Safety: Recall History of Royal Canin and Blue Buffalo

Both brands have a recall history over the years. But rest assured, they were quick to recall every product worldwide and fix the issues.

Royal Canin

Royal Canin has been recalled three times. First on February 2, 2006, because of the excess level of vitamin D3. Second on April 19, 2007, due to melamine content and last was on May 11, 2007, due to melamine content again.

For more than a decade, they have no more recalls. All thanks to their improved quality control measures. Royal Canin's safety standards are quite certain, so these things don't happen again. But still, it is a company that does mass production, so they should be expected to uphold food safety and quality at all times.

Blue Buffalo

Blu Buffalo has been recalled 9 times throughout the years. First, on April 26, 2007, for melamine. Another on April 19, 2007, for melamine again. Next was on October 8, 2010, for toxic levels of vitamin D. Another recall happened on March 3, 2017, due to a foil seal packaging problem. In the same year on the 14th of February, it was again recalled for the presence of aluminum. And again, on March 18, 2017, due to elevated beef thyroid hormones present on the products. And another two recalls in 2015 because of mold and the presence of Propylene Glycol. And the last one on November 25, 2015, because of Salmonella.

Some of the causes were naturally occurring, especially on canned or wet dog food. And these may show symptoms through frequent urination, weight loss, increased heart rate, restlessness, and increased thirst.

FAQs

Is Royal Canin better than Blue Buffalo?

It always depends on what your pets' needs are. The difference between the two brands is relatively small. So, to make everything safe and sure, as your veterinarian which brand is suitable for your pet. 

Why is Royal Canin recommended by Vets?

Royal Canin is always recommended by vets because it has gone through AAFCO feeding trials. Meaning, it guarantees high-quality products by following the highest standards of production and manufacturing.

Why is Blue Buffalo dog food the best?

Blue Buffalo is always considered to be one of the best because of the high-quality and natural ingredients used. Plus, all the dog foods they produced have no fillers or animal by-products.

Where can I buy Blue Buffalo and Royal Canin dog food?

Both brands are always available in any pet shops worldwide. It is also available in veterinary hospitals, as well as in grocery shops and chain markets. You can find them in your local Wal-Mart and Petsmart store, too.

Also, should you wish to buy them online, you can to their websites or on Amazon. 

julia
Julia is an animal volunteer and a Vet Tech she helps us with research and product evaluation. She also have worked in technical roles that help her sift through the marketing smoke screen. She is passionate about all animals and often helps out at shelters. 
crossmenu