Purina vs Pedigree

Comparison Of Purina vs Pedigree Dog Food In 2021 

Pedigree and Purina are two of the best and biggest dog food products in the market today.

Now, we will compare these two products and see if which one is better. More importantly, let us consider the different factors when choosing the best dog food–, nutritional value, ingredients and flavors, product safety, and cost.

Here it goes:

Nutritional Value

In terms of nutrient content, Pedigree is out-performed by Purina One. This is because Pedigree compromises nutrition in order to create a budget-friendly product. 
It means, it uses more low-quality animal by-products and filler grains. 
While Purina One contains more fiber, fat, and protein
Dry Dog Food
Pedigree Food
Purina One
Crude Protein
24%
31%
Crude Fiber
4%
4%
Crude Fat
11%
17%
Wet Dog Food
Pedigree Food
Purina One
Crude Protein
41%
45%
Crude Fiber
6%
7%
Crude Fat
21%
25%

Most Popular Pedigree Dog Foods In 2021

Pedigree Adult Complete Nutrition Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor Dry Dog Food

pedigree dog foodCheck Latest Price
Pedigree Adult Complete Nutrition Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor Dry Dog Food is formulated to help your dogs have enough energy and nourishment for their nourishment and development. It is also made with a delicious roasted chicken flavor plus B vitamins, zinc, and omega-6 fatty acid to keep them look better and shinier.

It has a guaranteed analysis of 21.0% min crude protein, 10.0% min crude fat, 4.0% max crude fiber, 12.0% max moisture, 100 IU/kg min vitamin E, 80 mg/kg min zinc, 2.0% min omega-6 fatty acid, and more.
Pros:
  • gives plenty of energy and pets' coats stay shiny
  • very affordable
  • good for multi-dogs households
Cons:
  • lower protein level

Pedigree Chopped Ground Dinner With Chicken Canned Dog Food

pedigree best dog foodCheck Latest Price
Pedigree Chopped Ground Dinner With Chicken Canned Dog Food is made with a ground texture that will make it easier for your dogs to chew. This dog food contains meaty feast levels of oils and minerals to promote healthier skin and a shinier coat. This balanced recipe provides complete nutrition and is highly digestible for easy nutrient absorption.

It has a guaranteed analysis of 8.0% min crude protein, 6.0% min crude fat, 1.0% max crude fiber, and 78.0% max moisture.
Pros:
  • very affordable
  • easy to digest
  • suggested for small dogs and puppies
Cons:
  • has a lesser amount of vitamins and minerals

Pedigree Small Dog Complete Nutrition Grilled Steak & Vegetable Flavor Small Breed Dry Dog Food

pedigree best small dog foodCheck Latest Price
Pedigree Small Dog Complete Nutrition Grilled Steak & Vegetable Flavor Small Breed Dry Dog Food is made for small breed dogs who need essential nutrition and a stronger immune system. These small, crunchy pieces help clean the teeth to support oral health and cleansing. It has optimal levels of Omega-6 fatty acids to nourish the skin and coat.

It has a guaranteed analysis of 21.0% min crude protein, 11.0% min crude fat, 4.0% max crude fiber, 12.0% max moisture, 2.0% min omega-6 fatty acids, 100 IU/kg min Vitamin E, 350 mg/kg glucosamine, and more.
Pros:
  • has a higher amount of protein
  • perfect for indigestion problems
  • contains vegetable for more vitamins and minerals
Cons:
  • contains more fillers and by-products

Most Popular Purina Dog Foods In 2021

Purina ONE SmartBlend Chicken & Rice Adult Formula Dry Dog Food

purinaCheck Latest Price
This product from Purina ONE uses chicken as the key ingredient, which is blended with high-quality protein sources that help support strong muscles and a healthy heart. It is also made of a dual antioxidant blend of vitamins E and A with zinc and selenium to provide a healthy immune system and radiant coat to your pets.

This dog food has a guaranteed analysis of 26% min crude protein, 16.0% min crude fat, 3% max crude fiber, 12% max moisture, 150 mg zinc, 0.35mg selenium, 250 IU/kg min Vitamin A, 250 IU/kg min Vitamin E, 1.6% min Omega-6 fatty acids, and more
Pros:
  • tastes so good for dogs
  • contains a high amount of protein
  • can give a shiny coat and full bellies
Cons:
  • expensive

Purina ONE SmartBlend True Instinct with Real Turkey & Venison Adult Dry Dog Food

purinaCheck Latest Price
Purina ONE SmartBlend True Instinct with Real Turkey & Venison Adult Dry Dog Food is formulated with real turkey, venison, and other high-quality ingredients that every pet owner is looking for. It contains 30% protein in every serving to provide strong muscles to your adult dog. Plus, it has double the number of meaty morsels compared to other flavors and is free from poultry by-products.

It has a guaranteed analysis of 30.0% min crude protein, 17.0% min crude fat, 3.0% max crude fiber, 12.0% max moisture, 150 mg/kg min zinc, 15,000 IU/kg min vitamin A, 460 IU/kg min vitamin E, and more.
Pros:
  • contains a low amount of sodium
  • reasonable price for a premium food
  • great kibble for a working dog
Cons:
  • the meaty morsel ingredient can be hard for dogs to chew

Purina ONE SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Adult Formula Dry Dog Food

purina lamb riceCheck Latest Price
Purina ONE’s SmartBlend Lamb & Rice Formula can certainly give your pets real lamb ingredients for their meal plus, it has other high-quality protein sources for stronger muscles and a healthier heart. It also contains Omega-6 fatty acids for a radiant coat and healthy skin, plus a natural source of glucosamine to help support healthy joints.

It has a guaranteed analysis of 26.0% min crude protein, 16.0% min crude fat, 3.0% max crude fiber, 12.0% max moisture, 350 ppm min glucosamine, 1.6% min Omega-6 fatty acids, 13,000 IU/kg min, and more.
Pros:
  • suggested for dogs who have skin sensitivities
  • suggested for picky-eaters
  • gives energy to the dogs
Cons:
  • expensive
  • has a lower amount of protein

What Is Crude Protein

Protein is an important nutrient in dog foods. Why do dogs need protein in their diet? According to health experts, protein contains all of the ten essential amino acids, which are helpful in the dogs' growth and sustenance.

Different dog food brands contain different amounts of protein, thus you should check out the label and the recommended amounts of proteins for your dogs to not underfeed or overfeed them with protein.

Take note, pets of the same breed and species might have different nutritional values since their body functions differently due to the environmental and health factors. They have a sensitive biological system which usually requires a balanced diet to grow and develop properly. Furthermore, their nutrition can protect them from diseases and various health problems.  

What Is Crude Fiber

The fiber content in your dogs' nutrition is very helpful in their digestive process. Though it seems like they can chew almost everything, they still encounter indigestion problems from their treats, meals, and other tiny things they ingest while playing outside. Furthermore, fibers are responsible for pushing digested substances into the small intestine where it is acted upon by bacteria present. It also helps to maintain a good level of bacteria and the proper functioning of the gut.

What Is Crude Fat

An ideal balanced diet should have at least 10% fat guaranteed by every pet diet. It is absolutely vital in your dogs' health to provide them sufficient amount of energy and serve a normal development and function to them. Fats help your dogs give prostaglandins that reduce inflammation and more. Fat content also helps in the absorption of vitamins in the body, which can maintain a healthy and shiny skin coat.

Ingredients and Flavors

Purina One is intricately formulated using various high-quality ingredients like ranch-raised lamb, brewer's rice, chicken, oatmeal, whole grain wheat, soy flakes, poultry by-product meal, carrots, peats, spinach, pea fiber, chicken stock and broth, ground wheat, turkey, turkey by-product meal, canola meal, whole barley, sunflower oil, caramel, glycerin, and vitamins and minerals. 

Flavors in Purina One includes:

  • Lamb and rice
  • Salmon and trout
  • Ground chicken and brown rice
  • Ground beef and brown rice

On the other hand, Pedigree's ingredients are also made of high-quality ingredients beef, wheat gluten, natural poultry flavor, ground yellow corn, meat and bone meal, vegetable oil, wheat flour, wheat meddling chicken by-product meal, caramel, iron oxide, dried plain beet pulp, brewers rice, salt, corn gluten meal ground whole grain, fructose corn syrup, tomato pomace, lamb, vitamins and minerals.

Flavors in Pedigree includes:

  • Biscrock gravy bones
  • Grilled steak and vegetable
  • Roasted chicken, rice, and vegetable
  • Meaty ground dinner with chopped chicken

Further, here are the Controversial Ingredients used by Purina One and Pedigree on their products:

  • Liver
  • Brewers rice
  • Wheat gluten
  • Corn gluten meal
  • Vegetable oil
  • Animal by-products
  • Animal fat
  • Caramel color

Product Safety

Sine 1986, Purina has been in operations and became part of the Nestle Purina PetCare group. Its distribution networks continue to widen in numerous countries worldwide with a headquarter in St. Louis, Missouri. Regarding its safety, it has only been recalled twice. Once in 2013 when it was triggered by a Salmonella outbreak although no pets were harmed and the contamination was only limited to a single bag. And another in 2016 when some of their wet dog food was issued to have no numbers of minerals and vitamins but nothing was proven to be dangerous.

While Pedigree had experienced numerous recalls over the years. In 2008, it was recalled because of potential Salmonella contamination, but no pets were harmed by eating the dog food. In 2012, bits of plastics found in food were examined that could give a choking hazard. Also, in 2014, another recall happened due to the presence of foreign material, specifically metal fragments. 

Purina vs Pedigree – Which is better?

Which one has more protein?

Purina One has more protein content, which is 31% compared to Pedigree that gives only 24%. For wet dog foods, Purina One has 45% while Pedigree only contains 42%.

Which one has more flavors?

Both Purina One and Pedigree offer several flavors for you to feed your pets. The Purina One has a total of 25 fry dog foods and 27 wet dog foods while Pedigree has only 10 dry dog food recipes but has 41 recipes for wet dog food.

Which one is cheaper?

Pedigree is cheaper since it focuses on its affordability which is why you can easily find it in almost every groceries. However, their affordable kibbles tend to compromise their quality since they rely on cheap fillers like corn and wheat. 

Which one had more recalls?

Pedigree has more recalls compared to Purina. However, no proven and published results have been made by the company.

Does Purina kill dogs?

No. If given in the right amount to your pet along with the direction from the veterinarian, then it will never compromise your dogs' health.

Does Pedigree kill dogs?

Just like Purina One, it is totally safe if being feed with the right amount and with the veterinarian's guidance.

Is Pedigree owned by Purina?

No. Pedigree is one of the brands owned by Mars Petcare, which is the largest pet food companies in the market. Some of the brands under the said company are Royal Canin, Whiskas, Nutro, Cesar, and more.

Is Pedigree dog food good?

Pedigree dog food is among the average dry food product for pets. Though it has grain-inclusive ingredients such as animal by-products as its main source of protein, it still can give your dog a good amount of nutrients.

Is Purina good for dogs?

Purina dog food is good and safe for dogs. It may not be the top and the best dog food for your pets but it can certainly fit your budget with having a good amount and high-quality of nutrients and vitamins into the body. 

staff 2
Ann is a long time lover of all animals - she has helped save over 350 pets and find them new loving homes. Ann loves to write about all animals share her knowledge gained over a lifetime of pet love and care.
crossmenu