Purina One vs Purina Pro Plan in July 2021

Purina Pro Plan vs Purina One. Purina is a popular company that has been known for producing high-quality pet supplies like dog and cat food. 

Two of the most popular brands they have are Purina One and Purina Pro Plan, both have excellent products and reputation in the market.

But between the two, which of them are better?

best Overall Purina Dog Food 2021

Purina Pro Plan
If You Want The Best
Check Latest Price

best Purina For Active Dogs 2021

Sport All Life Stages Performance
Dog's Love This
Check Latest Price

best Weight Control Dog Food 2021

Adult Weight Management Dog Food
Help your Dog Lose Weight
Check Latest Price
In this article, we look at both types of dog food products from this company and undertake thorough research on the differences and benefits between the two products.

These two popular dog foods may come from the same manufacturer but there are differences. You will see that each product has a different nutritional content and ingredients.

When choosing Purina Dog Food the ingredient content and essential vitamins and minerals are the most important factors in buying dog food.

What is the difference between Purina One and Purina Pro Plan?

Purina One

Pros:

  • Recipes are high in protein
  • Real meat is the first ingredient
  • Recognized for its premium quality food
  •  Great value

Cons:

  • Limited choice of flavors
  • Contains some controversial ingredients

Purina Pro Plan

Pros:

  • Has more probiotics
  • Offers a wider selection of flavors
  • Full of Omega fatty acids
  • Well-balanced ingredients

Cons:

  • Contains animal-by products
  • High in sodium
  • Contains cheap fillers

About Purina

Purina is a huge and renowned global company that is based in St. Louis, Missouri. It is now owned by Nestle and produces several lines of pet food products, including Purina One and Purina Pro Plan. The company is continually expanding with over 50 acres with 16 buildings that include a four-story research facility. 

In 1894, William H. Danforth founded the Robinson-Danforth Commission Company, which was the first balanced food production company in the world. In 1902, the company name transitioned into Ralston Purina and entered into a pet food business after acquiring some small companies. It focuses on researching and developing quality pet foods that contain full nutrition for animals. It is also an alliance between Purina and Dr. Ralston, a nutrition specialist.

In 2001, Nestlé bought Ralston Purina. The two businesses merged under the Purina brand and have been continuously expanding worldwide offering a broad variety of products for your pet's care and nutrition. Now, Purina continues to produce dog foods that vary according to different dietary needs and issues. It created one of the firsts pet food made from an extrusion or specified puppy formulas (kibbles) to address the special needs of puppies. Purina also conducted a 14-year study to develop hypoallergenic products for animals that fit their breeds, life stage, and nutrition.

"Responsibly sourced, expertly prepared, and nutritionally essential" is Purina's assurance to its customers. Until now, all their pet food products have quality ingredients made into different kinds of recipes with feeding guidelines. 

Purina One vs Purina Pro Plan Nutritional Value

Nutrients, vitamins, and minerals are important factors in improving the body's nutrition. The food choices we make determine how much nutrition we are taking in. However, humans and dogs aren't the same when it comes to food. Contrary to what everyone believes, dogs have different dietary needs than humans. Meat and protein are just a part of their needs to get a balanced diet. It takes many ingredients and nutrition in order to be at their best and that is where kibbles come in.

Both Purina One and Purina Pro Plan pass the standard amount of the three major components of dog food products which are protein, fats, and fiber with very slight differences. Take a look at this:

Purina One:

  • Crude Protein: 31.6%
  • Crude Fiber: 4.3%
  • Crude Fat: 17.2% 

Purina Pro Plan:

  • Crude Protein: 31.8%
  • Crude Fiber: 4.4%
  • Crude Fat: 17.9%

Protein

Both brands have roughly the same amount of protein content. This is an essential part of the nutritional value for dog foods since protein can prevent dogs from developing a wide-range of serious health problems. The protein content provides amino acids, which are very important for giving energy, cellular regeneration, healthy coat, skin, ligaments, and muscle production.  Dogs cannot produce protein naturally that is why it must be added to their daily diet. Meaning, poor-quality dog food can lead to the deterioration of your pup's immune system because of vitamin deficiencies. 

The only difference between the two brands is that Purina Pro Plan has more protein by point 2%. Both brands list real meat as their first ingredient but the meat by-products go next, which is a major downfall. Meat by-products are the most controversial ingredient since they are mostly made of ground rendered parts of poultry carcasses and contain bones, offal, and beak. It may not be totally harmful to your pets but it contains less to zero nutrition. 

Fiber

The fiber content helps in the dog's digestive system because of its ability to enhance food digestion and constipation since dogs tend to chew or swallow their food improperly. Both Purina One and Purina Pro Plus have sufficient fiber content in their products, it's just that Purina Pro Plan is higher by less than 1%. But both have done their research as to what constitutes a healthy balanced diet that would match your pup's needs. 

A lack of fiber on the diet can lead to severe constipation as well as problems in their digestive and anal glands. Fiber also aids in the absorption of nutrients from food in the gut. Basically, it is an all-around essential part of a healthy diet.

Fat

Fat content in dog food should be enough to aid the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins as well as improve your dog's palatability. The Purina Pro Plan has a higher content of fats by point 7%. If you think that your dog needs more fats in the diet, then you have to go for this product. Also, the suggested content of fat ratio from AAFCO is only 2:1. Meaning, the fat content of the Purina Pro Plan is higher than what is suggested by professionals. 

It is still important that your dog gains more nutrition from protein before getting it from fats. Too many fats in the diet cause overweight or obesity and could also lead to inactive pooches.

Winner

Purina Pro goes better when it comes to nutritional value. This product has more nutrient content and has a wide variety of formulas for your pup. Your dogs might thank you if it suits best with their taste.

Purina One vs Purina Pro Plan Ingredients

Both Purina One and Purina Pro Plan contain controversial ingredients that might cause allergic reactions to your sensitive dogs. Many of their products use these ingredients:

  • Brewers rice
  • Corn gluten meal
  • Animal by-products
  • Whole grain wheat
  • Animal fat
  • Wheat gluten
  • Soybean flour
  • Caramel color
  • Powdered cellulose

Here is the controversial ingredient that is only used by Purina One:

  • Turkey by-product meal

And here are the controversial ingredients that are only used by Purina Pro Plan:

  • Poultry
  • Garlic Powder
  • Corn grits
  • Chicken by-products
  • Dried corn syrup
  • Canola oil
  • Poultry giblets

Winner

We would choose Purina One when it comes to safer ingredients since we can see that Purina Pro Plan contains several controversial ingredients that may be harmful to your pets.

Purina One vs Purina Pro Plan Flavors

The flavor is an important factor when purchasing dog food for your pets. Like humans, dogs are always picky and can be bored of the same food served every day. Luckily, Purina made a variety of flavors according to their different brands. Also, most of their flavors have almost the same ingredients with just a slight difference. Meaning, you can easily transition your dog to different food flavors if he becomes bored with his usual food. 

Purina One's original flavor is chicken, corn, peas with lamb and rice, or chicken and rice as alternatives. Moreover, their dietary specification kibbles for puppies, adults, and sensitive dogs offer salmon & rice flavor, or salmon & tuna with added peas and carrots.

Purina One's popular flavors:

  • wholesome chicken and rice entrée
  • Salmon and trout recipe
  • Beef and rice entree
  •  Real salmon and tuna formula

On the other hand, Purina Pro Plan's standard flavor is chicken, rice, and corn. Kibbles for puppies, adults, and sensitive dogs have lamb & rice, salmon & rice, and chicken & egg recipes.

Purina Pro Plan's popular flavors:

  • HA hydrolyzed chicken formula flavor
  • Chunky chicken entrée and Savor shredded chicken and rice.
  •  Cesar gourmet wet
  • Salmon and rice formula

Winner

Purina Pro Plan has a better option for flavors compared to Purina One. Having a variety of flavors to choose from can give so much advantage to your dogs. Again, with Purina Pro Plan, you won't have a hard time switching to different flavors to address your dog's appetite and nutritional needs. 

Purina One vs Purina Pro Plan Cost

Affordability is another important factor that buyers consider when buying supplies for their pets. Even when a particular product meets the AAFCO standard, the price always plays a part especially if it is worth the quality or if the budget is tight. There have been several reports that brands exaggerate the prices and claim that it comes with extraordinary ingredients and benefits even if it shows the other way around. 

So, Purina One and Purina Pro Plan are both affordable when it comes to various sizes like 5lb and 16lb. Meaning, you can choose either of the two depending on your pet's preference and need. Nonetheless, Purina Pro Plan costs a little bit higher than Purina One. That is why some buyers prefer Purina One since it is cheaper and comes almost the same in quality when it comes to pet food. 

But it is no means that Purina Pro Plan is not worth your dollar. As we have stated above, it has more choices of flavors and also contains a little bit more nutritional value. But if you have a tighter budget for your pet's food, then go for Purina One since it is cheaper yet has good quality content, too.

Winner

Purina One is the more cost-efficient product. It has a lower cost plus, it offers high-quality ingredients. If your budget is a concern, Purina One is a good choice for your fur baby.

Purina One vs Purina Pro Plan FAQs

What's the difference between purina pro plan and purina one?

Q: What is the main difference between Purina’s product lines?
A: There is very little difference and both have a wide range recipes for all the life stages and health requirements for your loved pet. The quality of the kibbles and other products are high and have been popular with pet owners for a long time - many claiming their pets are healthy because of their diet.

A: The main difference is that Purina Pro Plan has a larger range of health specific recipes.

Which one is cheaper?

Purina One is more affordable than Purina Pro Plan.

Has purina pro plan had any recalls?

Both Purina One and Purina Pro Plan have had one recall throughout the years. Purina Pro Plan was recalled on March 9, 2016, due to incorrect vitamins and minerals while Purina One was recalled on August 30, 2013, due to salmonella.

Which one has more flavors?

Purina Pro Plan offers more flavors for your pets. It provides a variety of flavors according to your dog's nutritional needs and life stage. 

Which one is the tastiest?

Both are highly recommended by vets and pet owners. Actually, both product lines are the best-selling pet food in the market. But looking into reviews and results, both produce good quality products and have been the favorites for pets for several years.

Do vets recommend Purina One and Purina Pro Plan?

Yes. Purina, as a company, belongs to the few recommendations of WSAVA (World Small Animal Veterinary Association). 

Does Purina Pro Plan Contain Taurine?

No this had not added taurine - but it worth noting that taurine does occur naturally in meat and fish - but it is not added.

Does Purina Pro Plan Contain Grain?

No Grain - It is grain-free and also corn free. Also there is not rice flour, fish oil, brewer's rice, fish meal or soybean meal added that I could find.

Is Purina Pro Plan Healthy?

Yes it is a healthy dog food plan

Is Purina Pro Plan Dog Food Made In China?

Purina's website says that 99% of all their pet food products are made in the USA - some plant based protein is present and mixed with tocopherols.

Which is better purina pro plan or blue buffalo?

See Our Review here on Blue Buffalo

The Winner  purina pro plan or Purina One?

We like Purina Pro Plan - there is a bigger choice of Diets. 

Purina One and Purina Pro Plan have gained each of their own credibility and trust from their customers for cat food, dry dog food, wet dog food and is a really good dog food brand.They have been in the market for several years and proved their quality through the products they have been selling. One of the best benefits is that a nice healthy skin is often observed. Moreover, the suggestions listed above are based on reviews and facts stated by Purina. If you read it clearly, both are relatively similar, so it is up to you what suits best for your pet.

In the end, they all come from the same company, same researchers, and same manufacturers. The only way that you can see the results is to try and observe your pet's reaction.
julia
Julia is an animal volunteer and a Vet Tech she helps us with research and product evaluation. She also have worked in technical roles that help her sift through the marketing smoke screen. She is passionate about all animals and often helps out at shelters. 

best Overall Purina Dog Food 2021

Purina Pro Plan
If You Want The Best
Check Latest Price

best Purina For Active Dogs 2021

Sport All Life Stages Performance
Dog's Love This
Check Latest Price

best Weight Control Dog Food 2021

Adult Weight Management Dog Food
Help your Dog Lose Weight
Check Latest Price
crossmenu